I make chocolate chip or chocolate chunk cookies on and off for my daughter who likes them. They make great after school snacks and even excellent stuff for her to carry to school for her mid-morning break. I always pack quite a few for these because she likes sharing them with her friends. I have tried different recipes for them, and some have been better than others. Yet, I haven’t blogged a single chocolate chip cookie here so far. I don’t know why, and it certainly isn’t because I’ve never made really good chocolate chip cookies. I have!
Then I discovered these chocolate chip cookies and didn’t have any great expectations from them because they are made with whole wheat flour. If you’ve baked stuff with whole wheat flour, especially cakes and breads, you know that you don’t always get the texture that all-purpose flour produces. Sure you can be open minded and say that whole wheat bakes are pretty good but you will find that a lot of people will not agree with you, and will even give the “healthier” bakes a wide berth!
But these Wholewheat Chocolate Chip Cookies turned out so good that I knew I was definitely sharing them with you. No one even asked what was in the cookies, because I suspect they didn’t even realise it wasn’t good old white flour in them!
So why would someone resort to baking chocolate chip cookies with whole wheat flour? I won’t tell you that it’s because whole wheat flour is a healthier option. I’ll be honest and upfront and confess that it was because I ran out of all-purpose flour!
Whole wheat flour can be a healthier option than plain white flour in various other recipes but it would be stretching things beyond belief to claim that here given that these cookies contain quite a bit of butter and sugar (both of which I cut down a bit in my version). Add the chocolate chips to the mix and “healthy” flies out of your window! But the whole wheat flour gives these cookies a very nice flavour that’s not there in the regular kind.
I’m not much of a cookie eater and rarely eat the sweet ones. Savoury ones are more my thing. Most of the sweet cookies that I bake are for my daughter and her friends, our family, friends and neighbours. I would reach out for the occasional chocolate chip cookie and that too because they have chocolate in them. So when I tell you that these cookies are good, maybe you should take me seriously. Apparently there was a time not too long ago, when these cookies were all the rage on food blogs but I never saw them then. It was only when I needed to bake some cookies and had run out of regular flour that I went looking for a whole wheat chocolate cookie recipe.
The whole wheat flour gives it a nice taste and colour and if you like thick chewy chocolate chip cookies that hint at crispness around the edge, then these are for you. I would suggest using chopped chocolate chunks if you like largish chocolate bits in your bite of cookie. No one would even realise these are whole wheat cookies and you can watch the surprise on peoples’ faces when you reveal the “truth” after they’ve eaten them.
I’ll just mention a couple of things before I get to the recipe. The original recipe suggests using cold butter chunks but I let my butter become a little at room temperature (soft enough that when I pushed my finger into the still cold butter, it gave a bit). I just wanted to be a bit gentle and caring on the beaters of my hand held mixer. I did however chill the shaped cookie dough for a couple of hours before baking them, so that made up for it.
Chilling cookie dough gives them a better flavour and also produces thicker and chewy cookies. You can even freeze the shaped dough and bring out as many as you want to bake so you always can bake these cookies on demand!
I halved the original recipe and dec ided to substitute a little of the whole wheat flour with some cornstarch (1/8cup) for a better texture. An easy way to do this is by putting 1/8 cup cornstarch in your 1 1/2 cup measure and then making up the 1 1/2 cups by adding whole wheat flour. If you want make these egg-free, leave out the egg and add 1 1/2 tbsp water if the dough feels dry. Ideally, these cookies are best made with milled whole wheat flour, but I have made them successfully with atta/ whole wheat chapathi flour (Aashirvaad brand) as well.
Whole Wheat Chocolate Chip Cookies
(Adapted from Good to the Grain by Kim Boyce)